← notes

On Use of Weapons

by Iain M. Banks

Dark, very dark. Not entirely glad I read this. Rather, I am, but without the pleasant satisfied feeling that often immediately accompanies completing a novel. You know? When all the plot points and characters come together in a way that finally makes sense and resolves all the loose ends (except perhaps those that set up the subsequent novel)?

That doesn’t happen in this book. It all comes together, sure, but in a twisted, messed up way, that renders the book’s theme much clearer than I wanted and gives definite new meaning to the title: Use of Weapons.

The Culture needed a weapon and they found one. They found and forged one to suit their ends: Cheradenine Zakalwe (or is he?). His vice or virtue is largely irrelevant to the purpose, only his skill in the use of weapons to wage war, his predictability as an operator (by the standards of the Culture’s ‘minds’), and his intermittent death wish. They don’t even consistently deploy him on the side they want to win — and, if sometimes confused, he doesn’t seem to particularly care.

Is there a useful lesson or question or creative idea to draw from this book? Perhaps.

There’s a hypothesis embedded in the story that a ‘mind’ far, far beyond ours might not draw a line between strategy and tactics — that those might instead seamlessly flow, from one into the other, continually updating plans and using every unexpected setback or opportunity to optimal advantage. Opportunities, strategies, tools, weapons that we would never think of — would perhaps never know the existence of — become standard implements.

There’s a question posed: do intentions matter, or only impact? If you could determine impact with high confidence — if you know what will happen, and the intentions of your soldiers are predictable — what is and is not justified?

That said, I am quite tired of these questions as plot themes. They seem like the feigned moral quandaries of a misanthrope, searching for a fantasy scenario that justifies their nihilism (an apt characterization of the book’s protagonist). They remind me of the second Dune book, which I stopped reading because it took Paul’s emergent character complexity from book one and pushed it so far into the reader’s face that it’s no longer possible to empathize with him or find the tension in his development. It reminds me of Dalinar Kholin from the Stormlight Archive. It reminds me of streaming shows involving provocative anti-heroes and irredeemable leaders making repeated moral errors until no character remains virtuous or sincere — The 100; Battlestar Galactica (the 2000s version). What I imagine once seemed like novel, thought-provoking, morally nuanced introduction of anti-heroes has become a dull, dark trail of uninspiring figures.

This basking in moral ambiguity has ceased to resemble curiosity or thoughtfulness to my eyes. It resembles those few people I’ve encountered who seem too excited to discuss trolley problems, or the darker variation involving a surgeon and multiple patients. I recall, years ago, attending a college EA meeting where a drop-in from off campus brought up the moral tenability of blowing up factory farms (the host quickly noted a standing policy that such conversations could only take place after and outside of the formal discussion, so clearly it wasn’t the first time). The curiosity in these cases sometimes seemed an insincere cover for a kind of unhealthy intellectual luxuriation in the suspension of moral strictures. ‘One cannot wield power without doing harm’ is another, particularly lazy, variation I heard as an explicit claim only once or twice, but is a recurring theme in the fiction content.

I am both weary and disturbed by so many such characterizations of the world. If moral tension and complexity are warranted, then give me Dantès in The Count of Monte Cristo, nearly consumed by vengeance. Give me Frankenstein’s monster, or the priest of Victor Hugo’s Ninety-Three, who destroys himself and his beloved charge in accordance with his convictions. Those characters made errors of intention and will and bore costs. And their vitality and moral complexity are a world away from the many eerie passive compromises of contemporary anti-hero dramas.

That said, this book was not quite like the genre I criticize: it was far less expected and more disturbing, in a way that connected to the world-building and core idea of the novel. I was entertained during and devastated by the end, which I imagine is the goal. And, to be fair, Use of Weapons (1990) largely predates the trend I perceive.

There is only one direct plot connection to the next book — a character named Diziet Sma, who appears in the longest story in the collection, The State of the Art. The standalone nature of the stories effectively emphasizes the expansiveness of the timelines and universe. Still, the thematic overlap between Weapons and the first story of State of the Art is on-point. Use of Weapons highlights the contrast between The Culture’s idealism and the disturbing pragmatism of the ‘special circumstances’ arm. That story’s protagonist is understandably disenchanted by that same contrast, has gone rogue / renegade, and has been handed a weapon.

How strange, and how skillful, for Banks to have created so optimistic a universe with such distressing story lines.