I recently read Piranesi, by Susanna Clarke. At first I didn’t quite like it — the author just seemed to be setting up a sort-of irritating and stereotypical message about the malignancy of scientific ambition and the contrasting benefits of being at peace with and in collaboration with one’s surroundings. It was a bit of a knee-jerk, if grounded, reaction. Then it became something else entirely. Something strange, eerie, and ultimately peaceful.
A bit incongruously, Piranesi reminds me of the first season of Westworld, or the arc of Severance. Characters live unwittingly trapped in a kind of labyrinth — ostensibly a physical one, but really a mental one — until they find their way through and emerge with some newfound capability, won through their courageous escape. The labyrinth is created by those who wish to use knowledge and technology to oppress, but ultimately ruled by those who learn to navigate its challenges. The prison, at first, severs the protagonist from their self, but ultimately becomes the birth place of their re-integration and expanded capability.
The greatest novelty is Piranesi’s flavor of courage. It is peculiar — something built out of curiosity, thoughtfulness, and a desire to learn and understand. Instead of conquering his fears…he simply discovers them.
There is stark contrast between the text’s few characters. Piranesi lives because of dedication to meticulous comprehensive notes, a desire to explore, and an ability to adapt. His captor dies because he only interacts with the hall peripherally, exploiting it — and Piranesi — as tools of ill-will rather than genuinely seeking knowledge. In course, he is consumed by his own carelessness, fear, and hatred.
By the end, Piranesi has a realm of his own to enjoy and learn from. I envy the outcome, despite the melancholy and loss.
Can you imagine an endless gallery of sculptures, each conveying a different story and idea? What a wonderful place to escape from the world. We do have some such places in libraries and museums and the like, if none so vast and solitudinous. There is a whole world of statues at Scan the World, though there’s no space to walk yet.
I’ll appreciate those more I think, for having read this, and perhaps approach them differently.
I remember reading about memory palaces when I was 18 or 19 — I was so thrilled at the prospect of remembering anything and everything I wanted, like some customized encyclopedia. But Piranesi remembers nothing in the hall, leaving him only the sight of statues and dreams of statues. Perhaps it’s my age showing, or perhaps it’s easy access to AI answers, but if I built a memory palace today, I would fill it with more art. Not just for enjoyment, but as aesthetic consolidations of life lessons or resources of inspiration, as in Piranesi.