Frankenstein reads darkly. I’m glad I read it in the summer, and that the summer was unlike that of 1816, as the gloom is deeply felt (even in the 1831 version, which I happened to pick up first).
I gather there is an ocean of analysis regarding Shelley’s conscious intentions and unconscious influences when writing — e.g. her parents’ philosophies, the loss of her newborn daughter a year earlier, two dreams of reanimation…
All of those elements and more seem relevant or strongly apparent in hindsight. Yet, without any of that context, the story reads as perfectly internally complete. The story’s philosophical intensity is high, but reads nothing like a manifesto or treatise masquerading as a story. Every element Shelley built in fuels the narrative instead of distracting from it.
Moreover, the questions are complex, leaving ambiguity and uncertainty for the reader to contemplate. Would the Creature have turned out alright if Victor had remained with it? Or was it his careless rushed approach that doomed the project? Or is it the nature of a being that is stronger and more eloquent to conceive of malice readily — is the Creature simply human, but stronger and cleverer? Was the Creature honest? Did he account for the story accurately? Was Victor right not to create a mate for the Creature? And so on.
I had always imagined Victor’s destruction of the second Creature to be a reckless intuitive act, likely due to this memorable description:
As I looked on him, his countenance expressed the utmost extent of malice and treachery. I thought with a sensation of madness on my promise of creating another like to him, and trembling with passion, tore to pieces the thing on which I was engaged.
I must have read this section before because I recognized it. However, this time I noticed much more analysis of possible outcomes — near and long term — and awareness of the choices the second creature would have.
I was now about to form another being, of whose dispositions I was alike ignorant … He had sworn to quit the neighbourhood of man, and hide himself in deserts; but she had not … They might even hate each other …
one of the first results of those sympathies for which the daemon thirsted would be children, and a race of devils would be propagated upon the earth, who might make the very existence of the species of man a condition precarious and full of terror. Had I a right, for my own benefit, to inflict this curse upon everlasting generations?
I still cannot quite tell if his passionate destruction of the new Creature is partly him following through on his prior considerations, or if it is a more purely impulsive decision. It is interesting how similar it sounds to an AI safety discussion.
More lingering uncertainty surrounds the Creature’s truthfulness. I find he has a real Keyser Söze / The Usual Suspects feel. His story is masterful and impossible to verify. It almost feels too heartwrenching and well-told. The descriptions are vivid and believable, but the only evidence is the story and some letters. There’s this fragility to all of it, a deep eeriness of: this is so cohesive that it’s either all true or all fake. Moreover, the use of threats in addition to sympathy collapses the Creature’s credibility.
I think Shelley wanted the reader to ask these questions and be haunted by the uncertainty about the Creature’s nature, as Victor was. I imagine some read the Creature’s show of grief at Victor’s death to be conclusive, though, if I’m Walton, I remain profoundly wary.
Even as the moral challenges are powerful and provoke curiosity, it is also an adaptable read. Different readers can extract a range of different meanings and fears. Critical interpretations range widely, discussing motherhood, gender, nature, imperialism, and class.
In public, the Creature analogy is used liberally. There’s Trump as the GOP’s Frankenstein’s monster in 2016, Frankenfood to describe GMOs, and the bomb as either “Frankenstein or means for World Peace” in 1945.
In tragic contradiction of the novel’s own sympathies, the fearsome myth was used in political discourse to frame emancipation as monstrous, in reference to the West Indies in 1824 and the American South in 1831. Subsequent references to the story analogized the monster to the British working class, and Irish nationalism in 1882.
Perhaps the story is a Rorschach test of the intellectual environment that interprets it: do you sympathize with Victor or the Creature, and what real world analogies do you draw with them? The answers are telling.
I’m not sure how most individual readers actually react, but the last year of Amazon reviews mostly compare it with the movies and sympathize with the monster over Victor (e.g. “My little pookie creature deserved much better” — Kaitlyn).
I experienced the story as a harrowing account of the risks in the pursuit of knowledge in isolation and the ethics of experimentation — both physical and philosophical. I thought of every error I’ve made from rushing to completion, or from trying something new without the appropriate level of precaution. Injuries. Regrets. Not many, but enough.
Partly, I imagine the Creature as a representation of Victor, specifically, a piece of himself that is injured and alienated by his reckless experimentation. Eloquent, full of power and newfound knowledge, but no longer capable of belonging. Changed. Excommunicated from the human race. Abandoned, avoided, and despised by himself.
The flexibility holds though — it’s easy to compare the narrative with contemporary anxieties around AI and biology. Alignment concerns? Fear of replacement by something uncanny and powerful? Finding AI suspiciously persuasive and difficult to verify? Worried about lab leaks? Or infecting your family with covid? Pick a fear and it claws out the page.
The Creature is a lively and grotesque personification, so articulate about the injustice of his creation and abandonment, that, for a moment, any creative ambition seems frighteningly reckless and the source of inevitable tragedy. How remarkable that a 200 year old text can haunt me as both a horror story and a parable, but oh how I need to read an antidote next.
Where is the anti-Frankenstein? Where is the lesson applied to resolution? Surely not just in Walton’s abandonment of his trip north… surely that is not where the story ends. No. Even if he failed, it was Walton’s ambition that brought him to Frankenstein’s bedside to record the story and witness the Creature’s telling grief. If that is not the achievement he sought, it is still wisdom gained. No, perhaps he chooses a safer approach, or a different frontier, or to spend more time with his sister. I hope it is not the end of his ambition, but a change in its nature and the end of his solitude.
Is there another story? One where Frankenstein doesn’t isolate and develop mad experiments alone? Where he maintains connection with his friends and family, who render his temperament more patient and hopeful, as he openly discusses his ambitions?
Where is the scene when Frankenstein and a philosopher discuss ethics? Where is the careful research program that first develops organ transplants, or the restoration of lost limbs from the recently deceased to the living? Perhaps a better method of resuscitation for those near or just past death? Where is the research with animal models? Where is the paradigm shift that changes the field?
Most pointedly, where is the story of the medical care that would have spared Shelley’s first child, and rendered her dream needless? Reading the actual history of neonatal care could be a suitable means of recovery from the book's rich grief.
And perhaps there is another fiction tale to be written… one in which the protagonist is born of artificial means, and emerges into the world as caring, cared for, and named.
Though I am darkly tempted by the 1818 version.